Follow our live blog for the latest updates on the winter fuel payments vote in the House of Commons.
Rachel Reeves’ policy has prevailed this afternoon
MPs have voted by 348 to 228 in favour of Rachel Reeves’ plan to snatch Winter Fuel Payments of millions of hard-pressed pensioners this Christmas.
After the result was announced, opposition MPs were heard shouting “shame!” at Labour MPs who had backed the controversial policy.
The vote came after a high-tempered, and at some points furious, 90-minute debate, with opposition parties uniting to blast the Labour government’s policy.
The Tories, SNP, LibDems, Reform UK, Northern Ireland parties, the Greens and even some Labour MPs rose to object to the Government’s plan.
Had the vote passed, it would have been binding on the government and killed off the policy before Rachel Reeves even stands up to deliver her first budget next month.
The move means millions of hard-pressed pensioners will lose out on up to £300 this winter, despite the expected higher energy bills.
Stay tuned and follow the live blog below for all the fallout from this afternoon’s vote.
Tory MP says pensioners’ bus passes are now also under threat
A Conservative MP has warned that OAP bus passes are now also under threat from the Labour Government following today’s Winter Fuel vote.
Andrew Snowden warns: “I’ve just voted to save the winter fuel allowance – and Labour voted to cut it. But unbelievably a Minister at the dispatch box refused to rule out cutting free buses for pensioners.”
SNP leader claims Labour MP did ‘double fist pump’ during vote
The SNP leader in Westminster Stephen Flynn has claimed he saw one Labour MP do a “double fist pump” as the result of the vote to strip pensioners of their Winter Fuel allowance was announced.
Zarah Sultana accuses Government of implementing ‘austerity 2.0’
Labour rebel Zarah Sultana has accused Rachel Reeves of implementing “austerity 2.0”.
Ms Sultana, an independent MP was was sacked some weeks ago for also rebelling on the two-child benefit cap, added: “I just voted against the means-testing of Winter Fuel Payments.”
“I cannot stand idly by and see austerity 2.0 implemented.
“This is not the change people voted for.”
Age UK thanks MPs who voted against planned Winter Fuel cuts
Caroline Abrahams, Charity Director at Age UK said:
“We’re deeply disappointed, but not surprised, that the vote to brutally means-test WFP was passed today. As soon as the Government announced it was instructing its MPs to support it this was the inevitable result, but we would like to thank all those in every party who voted against the policy or abstained.
“There’s been a lot of discussion about the Government’s decision, but at heart Age UK’s critique of their policy is really simple: we just don’t think it’s fair to remove the payment from the 2.5 million pensioners on low incomes who badly need it, and to do it so quickly this winter, at the same time as energy bills are rising by 10%.
“It is crystal clear that there is insufficient time to make any serious impact on the miserably low take-up of Pension Credit before the cold sets in this autumn, and the Government has brought forward no effective measures to support all those whose tiny occupational pensions take them just above the line to claim. It’s true they have agreed to extend the Household Support Fund until April and they deserve some credit for that, but the HSF is an all-age fund that you have to apply for, so we know it will only help a small proportion of all the pensioners who will be in need as a result of their policy change.”
John Trickett breaks silence after becoming Labour’s only rebel MP
In a statement following his solo rebellion in this afternoon’s Winter Fuel vote, Labour MP John Trickett says he did so as he fears pensioners falling into poverty this winter.
Mr Trickett said: “I have voted against the government’s proposal to remove the winter fuel payment.
“The winter fuel payment was a great Labour achievement. When it was introduced by Gordon Brown in 1997, I was proud to vote for it.
“That Labour government had a transformative impact on pensioner poverty, which fell from 28% to 13% during our time in office.
“It shames our country that pensioner poverty has now risen to 18% after fourteen years of Conservative Party rule.
“This winter will be extremely difficult for my constituents of all ages. After years of obscene profiteering by energy companies, they are hiking bills yet again.
“I fear that removing the payment from pensioners will mean that many more will fall into poverty this winter.
“We know that the consequences of pensioner poverty are devastating. It can even be a matter of life and death.
“I have worked behind the scenes to try and change the government’s position, but to no avail.
“Our country is richer than it’s ever been, but the wealth is not shared fairly. In my view the government should be looking to raise revenues from the wealthiest in society, not working class pensioners.
“I could not in good conscience vote to make my constituents poorer. I will sleep well tonight knowing that I voted to defend my constituents.”
Mr Trickett explained his rebellion
Tories say the country should not forget today’s Winter Fuel vote
Commenting on this afternoon’s vote, Tory chairman Richard Fuller said:
“Labour just voted to cut Winter Fuel Payments for ten million pensioners in order to pay for inflation busting pay rises for their trade union paymasters.
“The country should not forget that Labour made a political choice to make this callous decision that will hurt pensioners just as their energy bills are set to increase this winter.
“Be of no doubt this is the start of Labour’s war on pensioners. People who have worked their whole lives and done the right thing, deserve dignity and security in retirement instead of being hung out to dry by this Labour government.”
Just one Labour rebel confirmed
Just one sitting Labour MP rebelled in the vote, according to the newly-published list.
John Trickett, MP for Normanton and Hemsworth and former shadow cabinet minister, voted with opposition parties to oppose the Winter Fuel Cuts.
However 10 left-wing independent MPs joined him, many of them having lost the Labour whip a few weeks ago when rebelling on the two-child benefit cap.
Reform UK say Labour MPs have shown ‘shameful disregard’ for pensioners
Commenting after the vote, Reform MP James McMurdoch has said: “Keir Starmer entered office on promises to protect pensioners. A promise broken almost immediately. Labour MPs today put party loyalty above the well-being of our elderly. By voting for these cuts or abstaining, they’ve shown a shameful disregard for the needs of millions of pensioners”.
“Cutting foreign aid, which we are legally able to do, would save billions of pounds, money that could and should be used to protect our pensioners during the coldest months of the year.
“Labour are bending over backwards to appease the unions, while at the same time taking money out of thousands of pensioners’ pockets and creating a miserable winter for millions more. This socialist and incompetent government is putting their party donations before our most vulnerable.
“Our pensioners should not have to face a bleak and insecure winter because of this government’s political choices. There are far better ways to save money that don’t involve targeting our elderly population.
“Only Reform UK will properly support our pensioners and ensure they are prioritised going forward.”
LibDems pledge to keep fighting Winter Fuel cuts ‘tooth and nail’
Responding to the vote to cut the Winter Fuel Payment, Liberal Democrat Work and Pensions Spokesperson Wendy Chamberlain MP said:
“Millions of pensioners will be left deeply worried about how they will get by this winter with this cut to the Winter Fuel Payment. So many pensioners are already facing another winter of a cost of living crisis and this will make things worse.
“The damage left by the Conservatives to our economy is unforgivable but cutting payments to vulnerable pensioners is no way to bring about the change the country deserves.
“Liberal Democrat MPs proudly opposed the Government today and stood up for the many pensioners across the country who are now at risk of an even bigger winter cost of living crisis.
“We’ll keep fighting this cut tooth and nail anyway we can, we’ll continue to be a constructive opposition to the new Government and we’re fighting for the real change people want to see.”
Exact result of today’s crunch vote announced
MPs have voted in favour of Rachel Reeves’ plan by a majority of 120 to scrap Winter Fuel Payments for millions of pensioners.
348 MPs voted in favour of the Government’s plan of action, with 228 voting against.
While the breakdown of how each MP voted is yet to be published, the announced numbers suggest that as many as 56 Labour MPs did not vote, with suggestions the party whips quelled a rebellion by asking those opposed to the policy to stay at home.
MPs begin voting
The division bells are ringing, and MPs are now voting following Liz Kendall’s high-tempered defence of the Government’s triple lock policy.
We should know the result in 15-20 minutes.
Kendall defends winter fuel payment cuts
Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall has accused the Conservatives of “faux outrage” over the winter fuel payment.
The minister said: “I would say to the faux outrage of members opposite, the faux outrage of members opposite who left 880,000 pensioners, the very poorest, not getting the pension credit they’re entitled to.
“And I would urge all honourable members to work with us and their local councils to make sure pensioners get the money they’re entitled to.”
She also told the Commons: “As my right honourable friend the Chancellor (Rachel Reeves) and the Prime Minister (Sir Keir Starmer) have said, this is not a decision we wanted or expected to make, but when we promised we would be responsible with taxpayers’ money, we meant it, because we know what happens when members opposite played fast and loose with the public finances.
“Working people and pensioners on fixed incomes paying the price with soaring interest rates, mortgages and inflation.”
Former Labour shadow Chancellor makes passionate speech against Reeves’ cuts
Ex-Labour shadow chancellor John McDonnell has made a passionate speech slamming Rachel Reeves’ policy of harming some of his poorest and most vulnerable constituents.
Mr McDonnel fumed: “I just think we’re in an unnecessary position, when there’s so much else we could be doing. We don’t need to put the burden on the poorest, we need to make sure that those who can afford it can pay… We don’t have to be here!
“[This decision] was based around misjudgement, and certainly flies against everything I believe in as a Labour MP about tackling inequality and poverty in our society.
“I was not elected to impoverish my constituents and put them in this hardship!”
Labour MP urges Government to delay policy
Labour MP Rachael Maskell, who has been vocal on the winter fuel payments axe, urged the Government to delay and rethink the policy.
She said: “We are getting the letters coming in, we are looking at the figures that our constituents have to look at every single day. And they are scared.
“They are telling us they are frightened, because they won’t switch the switch. Because they know if they do, they will have bills that they cannot pay. And we need to protect those very vulnerable people.”
The York Central MP said that pensioners would further be deterred by applying for pension credit as they would have to answer 243 questions on the application form, and then wait a nine-week wait.
She later added: “It’s my conscience that I cannot vote for these measures, but I am determined to work with government to find the mitigation that is absolutely crucial. Age UK say it’s too late to find alternatives, they say delay, I say, let’s delay.”
York Central MP Rachael Maskell
Green MP calls out Labour MPs’ absences from crucial debate
Green Party MP Sian Berry has called out the “disappointing” turnout from Labour MPs for the crunch Winter Fuel debate.
Ms Berry, who described the policy as the “Winter Fuel Robbery”, said Labour MPs’ non-attendance is a “disappointing sign they answer only to their whips – not to their constituents or their conscience”.
The Express hears a number of Labour frontbenchers have also been slipped by the party whips, allowing them to miss the debate and vote.
Father of the House accuses Labour of ‘punishment beating’ against pensioners
Sir Edward Leigh, the Father of the House, accused the Government of issuing a “punishment beating” against pensioners by cutting the winter fuel payment.
The former Conservative minister said there should be a “serious debate” about the total package given to pensioners, noting he has previously questioned aspects of the triple lock.
He told the Commons: “It’s a very difficult debate but I do understand that the total package paid to pensioners as a proportion of gross national product must not keep increasing every year because that is the way ultimately to bankrupt the country, and we need to have a social contract between older people, like myself, and younger people, particularly in terms of housebuilding.”
Sir Edward raised concerns for people who receive a small occupational pension but are not eligible for pension credit, saying they are “looking after every penny” but will suddenly lose the winter fuel payment.
He added: “I tell you what this is all about, this is about a punishment beating.”
Sir Edward described the “so-called £22 billion black hole” as a “mere accounting device”, adding: “What the Labour Government is now trying to do is to make the political point that the Conservative Party ran the country into the ground and therefore we’ve got to punish the pensioners. It’s absolute and complete rubbish.”
McVey blasts Starmer over winter fuel cuts
Tory MP Esther McVey launched a blistering attack on Sir Keir Starmer over winter fuel payment cuts.
She said: “Who would have thought a Prime Minister not even in office for 10 weeks would be so out of touch with the public?
“Yet here we are, and yes this Prime Minister is, along with the Chancellor and the whole of his Cabinet who are going along with and supporting this cruel policy.
“The Chancellor should be under no illusion that the public knows this decision to rob millions of pensioners of the winter fuel allowance, for which the Government has no mandate, has nothing to do with economics and everything to do with cynical political calculation. The haste with which it is being done is breathtaking.”
She added: “Labour has basically declared war on pensioners which will neither be forgotten or forgiven. Our pensioners deserve better than this.”
Esther McVey took aim at the Prime Minister
Scrapping winter fuel allowance is ‘simply wrong’ – Lib Dems
Wendy Chamberlain, the Liberal Democrat spokesperson on work and pensions, said: “We on these benches accept that the new Government has been left with an unenviable task of re-building our economy after the mess left by the previous government, and nobody is disputing that years of Conservative mismanagement have left the public finances in crisis.
“But this cut is simply wrong, it is wrong to strip support from many of the poorest pensioners, just as energy bills are set to rise again, it is wrong to force vulnerable elderly people to make that choice between heating and eating this winter, and it is the wrong answer to the challenges that we face.”
She added that the Government has “not properly thought through the consequences or the measures that will be available to support those most in need”.
Intervening, SNP MP Pete Wishart (Perth and Kinross-shire) said Scotland would be “disproportionally hit” by the policy due to its colder climate.
Ms Chamberlain (North East Fife) went on to say that “there is cruelty at the heart of this cut” and the Liberal Democrats will be “supporting this motion”.
Stride urges Labour MPs to ‘look to your conscience’
Addressing Labour MPs, shadow work and pensions secretary Mel Stride said: “Can I make an impassioned plea to those sitting opposite – look to your conscience. You know in your heart that these measures are wrong.
“You know in your heart that the party opposite has broken their promises and that these measures are going to lead to untold hardship for millions of elderly and vulnerable people right up and down this country.
“You now have an opportunity to join with us and put a stop to it.”
Stride attacks Labour over public sector pay offers
Shadow work and pensions secretary Mel Stride accused Labour of prioritising public sector pay rises “on the backs of vulnerable pensioners”.
Mr Stride said: “The fact that we even have a debate today is near miraculous, given the resistance from the party opposite. It is, of course, because of the scrutiny that this side of the House, this Conservative Party, is providing to this Government.”
He went on: “Of course, all politics is about choices, and what this Government has done is it has caved in to its trade union paymasters. It has settled way above inflation, junior doctors 22%, train drivers 14% and what it has done is it has stood up for the trade union paymasters on the backs of vulnerable pensioners. And that is not right.”
Mr Stride challenged Government MPs who had not received payments from trade unions to make themselves known in the Commons chamber.
He added: “If it’s not the case that the trade unions are running the Labour Party, hands up, everybody opposite who has not received some money from the trade unions.
“Hands up, anybody has not received money from the trade unions for their campaigning or their private office? One person, one person?”
As no hands went up on the Government benches Mr Stride concluded: “Therein lies the truth, the truth about who is running the Labour Party.”
Stride praises Daily Express’s winter fuel payment campaign
Mel Stride praised the Express for doing a “sterling job” in raising awareness of the impact of winter fuel payment cuts.
The shadow work and pensions secretary told the Commons: “The fact that we even have a debate today is near miraculous given the resistance from the party opposite.
“It is of course because of the scrutiny that this side of the house, the Conservative Party, is providing to this Government.
“We know also the petitions that have been railing against these measures. Silver Voices 100,000 people, 38 Degrees a third of a million, Age UK over half a million people calling on this Government to think again.
“The press particularly the Express newspaper doing such a sterling job in bringing these matters to the attention.
“Even the trade union movement, Unite pointing a finger at this Government saying it is picking the pockets of pensioners.”
Stride accuses Labour of ‘broken promises’
Shadow work and pensions secretary Mel Stride has accused the Government of “broken promises already”.
He told the Commons: “Labour candidates up and down the country gleefully pointed to their manifesto as having no mention of doing anything on this particular matter.
“But look within a matter of a few short weeks, what has happened? What happened to integrity? What happened to transparency? It went out of the window.
“Broken promises already, that special contract that they sought to have with the British people based on integrity and decency smashed into a million pieces.”
Mr Stride added: “The party opposite may say they’re going to have these wonderful campaigns that’s going to get everybody that’s entitled onto pension credit. The reality is that even if they did that that would see a cost to the exchequer of £3.8 billion which is over twice the money they say they are going to be saving.
“This is an absurd policy which their own plans are actually actively working against, and the haste with which this has been carried out is simply jaw dropping. We do not have any impact assessments. We do not know what the impact will be across the income distribution. Every member of this House does not know what the impact will be within their own constituency.”
Winter fuel payments debate begins
Shadow work and pensions secretary Mel Stride has kicked off the Commons debate on winter fuel payments.
The debate will last for around an hour and a half meaning a vote is expected at around 3pm.
Shadow work and pensions secretary Mel Stride
No plans to widen eligibility to winter fuel payment – No 10
There are no plans to widen the eligibility to the winter fuel payment, Downing Street has said.
“There’s no such plans,” a Number 10 spokeswoman said when asked by journalists on Tuesday.
Asked whether encouraging people who are eligible but not yet signed up for pension credit could wipe out the savings from restricting the allowance to the country’s poorest pensioners, she said: “The issue is that this policy has not been targeted previously… in line with that as well, it is right that anyone eligible for income-related benefits or pension credit is receiving it, and that’s why we’re making efforts to ensure that those who are eligible are converted on to it.”
Downing Street would not say whether Sir Keir Starmer had spoken to MPs ahead of Tuesday’s vote as it does not comment on “MP engagement”.
Cross party MPs put on show of unity over saving winter fuel payments
Fantastic cross-party turnout for the Express rally against winter fuel cuts.
Two Tory leadership contenders as well as many of the party’s MPs, Reform and the Greens.
Silver Voices, Age UK and the National Pensioners Convention also in attendance.
MPs gather at College Green in support of saving winter fuel payments
‘Plenty’ of wealthy oensioners don’t need winter fuel payments, Labour pensions minister says
There are “plenty of very wealthy pensioners” who do not need the winter fuel payment, according to a work and pensions minister.
Emma Reynolds said the Government was taking the decision to means-test the payment due to a “£22 billion black hole” in this year’s public finances “left by the previous government”.
She told a Westminster Hall debate: “In protecting the poorest pensioners on the lowest incomes and with the greatest need, it is the right decision given the tough choices that we face.
“Just to be very, very clear, I have spoken to a number of (MPs) present about the Government’s decision and there actually is fairly widespread agreement that this benefit should not be universal.
“There are plenty of very wealthy pensioners who are getting transfers of £200, or £300 if they’re over 80, into their bank account and who don’t need it, so it’s right that we target this support on the poorest pensioners.”
Ms Reynolds highlighted mitigation measures introduced by the Government, including extending the Household Support Fund, and said it was a “national scandal” that the previous Conservative government had not done more to increase uptake of Pension Credit.
Government ‘must have capacity to find another way’, Labour MPs says
Labour MP Rachael Maskell told a Westminster Hall debate: “A constituent has had leukaemia, they need to keep warm and have their heating on but cannot afford to, it costs £300 a month. A recently widowed constituent at the depth of their personal sadness now scared they will not survive the winter, they can’t afford their heating.
“Another goes to bed at five o’clock to keep warm. One told me he wears jumpers, a coat and a warm hat but the air is still cold and damp. And Rose, registered as severely visually impaired who lives alone, said ‘I’m a council tenant with no extra assets’. She went on to tell me she was scared, abandoned was her words – the winter fuel payment was her lifeline.”
Ms Maskell said the Government “must have the capacity to find another way”, adding: “They (pensioners) put their hope in Labour because, like me, we believe that we exist to fight for working people, to protect the poor and seek justice, equality and fairness.”
Ms Maskell said the economic imperative of the measures has been “shredded” before encouraging delays to implementing the policy, saying: “My constituents plead I do something, my goodness I am trying but the minister must too.
“Please, let us mitigate, let’s give people the confidence that we have, the comfort and care they need, help and protection to keep safe, warm and well this winter. If it can’t be done then delay these regulations.”
Labour MPs splams ‘nine-week wait’ for answer on pension credit form
Labour MP Rachael Maskell (York Central) welcomed Government moves to encourage more people to sign up to Pension Credit to ensure they receive the winter fuel payment, but said there is a “nine-week wait” once the 243-question application has been submitted.
She told a Westminster Hall debate: “Charities say it can’t be done in time, there is a reason why 37% of those eligible haven’t claimed it. It’s complex, there’s pride, some have dementia and complex needs, others simply find the thought too stressful, but please sign up.”
Ms Maskell added: “Demand on GPs sadly will rise, queues at A&Es will grow, more beds occupied in the NHS, and social care under more demand. Tragically, according to UCL and the Institute of Health Equity, there were 4,950 excess winter deaths due to cold homes under the previous government.
“I feel sick to the stomach each time I repeat this reality as I can’t process how governments past did not protect these vulnerable people. Labour must be different. We need mitigation, as we must protect those under our care or what is the point of power?”
Pensioners are considering riding buses to keep warm this winter
Pensioners are considering riding on a bus in a bid to keep warm following cuts to the winter fuel payment, MPs have heard.
Liberal Democrat MP Victoria Collins said several Harpenden and Berkhamsted constituents have written to her to express concerns, with an elderly couple saying they will “slip through the net and are considering going around on a bus to keep warm in winter”.
Winter fuel payment vote likely to be delayed
Defence Secretary John Healey will deliver a statement in the House of Commons at lunchtime to provide MPs with an update on the situation in Ukraine.
That means the debate on scrapping winter fuel payments will likely be delayed by around an hour.
This means the debate will begin at around 1.30pm, with a vote at 3pm.
Labour MPs warn of ‘humanitarian cost’ from winter fuel payment being axed
Labour MPs have questioned the economic case for Government cuts to the winter fuel payment, warning the policy will also have a “humanitarian cost”.
Rachael Maskell, the Labour MP for York Central, said a Labour Government “must always protect the poorest in our society” before questioning the likely savings of the policy to limit the winter fuel payment to only those people claiming Pension Credit or other means-tested benefits.
Labour MP Andy McDonald told a Westminster Hall debate: “The winter fuel payment regulations amendment will take up to £300 per household from two groups of low-income pensioners – those eligible for Pension Credit who do not claim it and those who are just over the pension cliff edge but still living on very little.
“As I understand it, the Pension Credit take-up is around 63% and this will at best be 68% and the saving to the public purse is predicated on that basis, but the savings will be wiped out if everyone eligible took up the Pension Credit, which surely should be the goal.
“Does she agree with me that this simply doesn’t stack up?”
Ms Maskell replied: “I think (Mr McDonald) has done the maths and I think it speaks for itself. The Chancellor cannot therefore make this just an economic argument as there is also a humanitarian cost too, and we need to have the capacity to find that escape route, as (former Treasury minister) Ed Balls stated, as people need a safety net.”
Want more political coverage from the Express?
Sign up for our politics newsletter and join our Whatsapp Community
Sir Keir Starmer insists Labour will not be reckless with taxpayer money
Sir Keir Starmer has told the TUC conference “we won’t be reckless” with people’s money, hours before MPs vote on cutting winter fuel payments.
Sir Keir Starmer says he will make ‘no apologies’ for Labour decisions
Sir Keir Starmer has said he will make “no apologies” for any of the decisions his Government has had to take.
His comments come amid a crunch debate and vote in the Commons on winter fuel payments today.
To read the full story on the Prime Minister’s comments, visit this story
Nigel Farage slams Labour’s decision to axe winter fuel payments as a ‘disgrace’
Reform leader Nigel Farage took to X, formelry Twitter, to blast Labour.
See his post below:
How much will cutting the winter fuel payment save the Treasury?
Under the plans, the winter fuel allowance for pensioners will be limited to only those claiming pension credit or other means-tested benefits.
It is expected to cut the number of people receiving the payment of up to £300 by 10 million, from 11.4 million to 1.5 million, which the Government hopes will save about £1.4 billion this year.
The Tories accused Labour of having failed to “properly examine” the implications of the policy.
Cabinet ministers concerned about impact of winter fuel payments being scrapped
Cabinet ministers are among those who have significant concerns about cut to winter fuel payments, report have suggested.
One said it has become a “massive issue on the doorstep” and the government “is at risk or ignoring the danger”.
Another warned that the cuts risk pushing pensioners into poverty
Winter fuel payment petition surges to nearly 100,000 signatures – add yours now
A petition demanding Rachel Reeves reverse her “callous” decision to axe the winter fuel payments has amassed almost 100,000 signatures.
Silver Voices, an over60s campaign group, has been fighting hard for Labour to u-turn.
To sign their petition, visit https://www.change.org/p/save-the-winter-fuel-payment
Key timings on winter fuel payment for today
At 12.30pm, the debate on scrapping winter fuel payments should start in the Commons. If there are urgent questions or ministerial statements, the start time will be delayed. The debate will last for 90 minutes.
If the debate starts at 12.30pm, then MPs should vote on winter fuel at around 2pm. The motion MPs will vote on would annul the Government’s winter fuel policy if it were to pass. But Labour’s significant majority means this is unlikely to happen.
Sir Keir Starmer has insisted Labour must ‘secure’ economy’s foundation with winter fuel payment cut
The decision to axe the winter fuel payment for millions of pensioners has faced criticism from many Labour MPS, but Sir Keir Starmer said Labour must “secure the foundations” of the economy.
Sir Keir said: “If you’re asking whether I recognise it’s a tough decision I absolutely recognise the tough decision. If you’re asking, would I want to make this decision, the answer is no, but I did not want to inherit a £22 billion, and I’m not prepared to walk past that.”
Pensioners losing winter fuel payments to be £300 worse off in real terms next April
Former pensions minister Sir Steve Webb, who is now a partner at pension consultants LCP (Lane Clark & Peacock), said: “Part of next April’s increase is simply to keep pace with rising prices.
“Based on the current inflation figure of 2.2%, the new state pension would need to rise by just over £250 simply for pensioners to stand still.
“Whilst an above-inflation increase of £460 will be welcomed, only the further £210 represents a real increase.
“And this is before allowing for the income tax which most pensioners will pay on their state pension rise.
“Those who lose £200 or £300 in winter fuel payments will therefore still be worse off in real terms next April.”
State pension set to rise by £460 next April
The full state pension is set to rise by £460 from next April, according to official wage figures.
The Office for National Statistics (ONS) said total pay increased by 4% in the three months to July.
While this is the lowest increase for nearly four years, it will mean pensioners who reached state pension age after April 2016 can expect to see their full, flat-rate state pension go up to £11,962.60 a year from next April – a rise of £460.
Under the triple lock, the state pension increases every April in line with whichever is the highest of average total earnings growth in the year from May to July of the previous year, CPI inflation in September of the previous year, or 2.5%.
As inflation is not expected to be higher than wage growth, the wages figure is likely to be used for the calculation.
But the figures are subject to possible revisions in next month’s data and the Government will confirm the planned increase in the autumn.
Labour have ‘completely rushed’ winter fuel payments axe – Stride
Shadow work and pensions sectetary Mel Stride told Times Radio: “We would not be going ahead with means testing the winter fuel payment.
“And I guess the point you might be making and it’s a fair one, of course, is there are some people who are millionaires, multimillionaires, or whatever, who clearly don’t need it.
“But the issue here is that the way the system works is that if you means test, you end up going much, much deeper than that and into millions of pensioners, actually, who are on extremely low incomes.
“And in fact, of the two thirds of the pensioners who are living below the poverty line will lose the winter fuel payment as a consequence of the measures that this Government is taking. It’s completely the wrong thing to do.
“They’ve done it at the same time as paying out to their trade union paymasters, very large wage increases, 22% over two years, junior doctors, 14% for train drivers, and above inflationary increases elsewhere.
“And this has been completely rushed. There’s no need to do this as quickly as the Government has done, other than for purely political reasons.
“And it means that the implications of this, of course, have not been properly examined in the normal way that they would be, and which is why even trade unions such as Unite has described this as picking the pockets of pensioners.”
MP warns winter fuel policy will result in pensioner deaths
Richard Burgon, who was one of seven Labour MPs who had the whip suspended earlier this year for rebelling over the two-child benefit cap, told LBC: “I think this cut will result in the deaths of pensioners who won’t be able to turn the heating on.”
He added that there was “no way” he could vote with the Government on the proposals.
He said: “I personally can’t look pensioners in my constituency in the eye… and kick them in the teeth like this.”
Burnham calls for winter fuel rethink
Andy Burnham, the Labour Mayor of Greater Manchester, urged the Government to reconsider its approach to axing winter fuel payments.
He told the BBC Radio 4 Today programme: “I also think there is a case for reform of the winter fuel allowance, I would just ask the Government not to rule out the possibility of a higher threshold, or indeed a taper of winter fuel allowance. Because our experience in Greater Manchester is that pensions are often reluctant to apply for the pension credit for a number of reasons.
“And actually, anyway, the threshold at which you get is pretty low anyway. And so I recognise how difficult the situation is and I do think there is a case, as I said, for reform, but I would ask them not to rule out putting in that possible extra help for pensioners who are right at that cliff edge.”
Minister would not guarantee that no pensioner would die of cold
Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds would not guarantee that no pensioners would die of cold as a result of the Government’s plans to cut the winter fuel payment.
“No-one should die of cold in this country,” the minister told Sky News.
Repeatedly asked whether he could guarantee that not one pensioner would die of cold, Mr Reynolds said: “I can guarantee we’re doing everything we can to make sure that not only the state pension is higher and everyone is better off but that support is targeted where it needs to be.”
Reynolds insists Government has ‘no choice’ over slashing winter fuel
Asked why the policy to restrict winter fuel payments was not in the Labour election manifesto, Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds told Sky News the party “did not know the situation we would inherit”.
Pressed why it was pursuing the measure, he said: “We have no choice.”
It was put to him that pensioners had been given no time to prepare, to which he replied: “The nature of what we’ve inherited and the challenges that that presented required some immediate decisions.”
Minister calls on Labour MPs to back winter fuel axe
Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds urged Labour MPs to back the Government’s cut to the winter fuel allowance in a vote on the plans later on Tuesday.
Speaking on Times Radio, he said: “Fixing the foundations of the country isn’t just about difficult things like this, which are decisions that ideally you wouldn’t have to make. It’s about how you get to a better future.
“And that is exactly what we’re trying to do and that is what I would ask all colleagues to recognise and support today.”
Reform MPs to vote against winter fuel cuts
Reform UK leader Nigel Farage said his party’s MPs will vote against Labour’s plans to strip millions of pensioners of winter fuel payments.
In a video on X, the Clacton MP said: “So the big vote on the winter fuel allowance, let’s be clear, Reform will vote against this benefit being removed.
“Already we pay the highest energy bills in the whole of Europe, massively higher energy bills than they do in America.
“And given the plans that Ed Miliband has put forward our bills will only go up over the course of the next 10 years.
“For that reason above all, we’re going to vote against the removal of the winter fuel allowance.”
Everything we know about winter fuel payment vote
The Express has rounded up all the key information on the winter fuel payments vote.
MPs will vote on controversial plans to restrict the allowance to all but the country’s poorest pensioners.
Good morning
Welcome to our live coverage of the winter fuel payments vote in the House of Commons which will take place this afternoon.
Follow our blog for the latest news and updates.