PM Keir Starmer and chancellor Rachel Reeves are launching a war on savers by stripping away the incentives people have to save for their future. It could backfire horribly.
Rachel Reeves says ‘we will turn our attention to pensions’
Labour’s savings grab won’t just hit the wealthy. As we saw with the shock withdrawal of the Winter Fuel Payment, millions on low incomes will be swept up in the assault.
There’s no stopping it with Starmer warning that tax rises are inevitable: “There is a Budget coming in October, and it’s going to be painful.”
A new threat emerges almost daily, as an army of left-wing think tanks and trade unionists urge Reeves to impose ever harsher levies on older, supposedly wealthy, Britons.
The Fabian Society, to name just one, wants Labour to launch a triple pensions tax raid. This would see Reeves slash tax relief on pension contributions, curb the hugely popular 25% tax-free pension lump sum, and make any unused pension subject to inheritance tax on death.
It has even called for Labour to slap national insurance on private pension income, someth ing retirees don’t pay today.
Strangely enough, nobody is calling for a curb on public sector pensions, even though they’re far more generous in practice.
Another think tank, the Resolution Foundation, wants Reeves to impose a lifetime cap on tax-free Isa savings of £100,000, in another tax on savers.
Today, everyone can save £20,000 a year, and build up as much pot as they want free of HMRC. So cutting the maximum holding to £100k would be a huge blow.
This is on top of hiking capital gains tax and inheritance tax, and possibly a wealth tax. Labour is after anyone who builds up modest wealth. As ever, the super-rich will slip free.
Buy-to-let landlords have been targeted for years even though most are ordinary savers with just one or two rental properties to top up their retirement income.
Now many are sick of being demonised and simply giving up. It wouldn’t take much for savers to give up, too.
Craig Rickman, personal finance and pensions expert at Interactive Investor, said Reeves risks eroding the appeal of saving into a pension at the worst possible time. “The government needs to incentivise people to beef up their retirement pots to avert the looming retirement crisis.”
Instead, it seems more likely to deter them, he added.
We’ve been here before. In 1997, former Labour chancellor Gordon Brown’s notorious stealth tax raid destroyed private sector final salary pensions forever, while leaving public sector schemes untouched.
Rickman said savers need confidence in the pension system as they save over decades. “Chopping and changing tax rules may damage confidence and harm engagement.”
People aren’t saving anyhere near enough for retirement already. Soon they’ll save even less.
Labour chancellor Rachel Reeves looks set to tax pensions and Isas harder in her Budget
This won’t just affect the better off. Lower earners with smaller pots will also fall victim to Labour’s war on savers.
Many are already are already punished for setting money aside as they risk losing means-tested state benefits such as Pension Credit.
A successful Pension Credit claim acts as a gateway for a string of state support, including Housing Benefit, Council Tax Reduction, the Warm Home Discount and free TV licences for those over 75.
Stephen Lowe, group communications director at Just Group, said the average claim is worth £2,200 year. “Once you add the other benefits, it can be worth £8,000.”
The income from a small pension could cost someone thousands in lost Pension Credit. And thanks to Reeves, they’ll now lose their Winter Fuel Payment too.
Savers are already being punished for trying to stand on their own two feet. Now Labour is going to make it worse.
Reeves could single-handedly destroy the UK’s savings culture, as millions wonder why they bother. We will all be poorer as a result.